When a Warner Bros. representative announced previous week that “Scooby-Doo” character Velma Dinkley would be reprised as East Asian in Mindy Kaling’s new grownup HBO Max clearly show, Twitter went into a frenzy with racist and Scooby traditionalist comments.

“Well she’s not Velma then is she,” a person person tweeted. 

“velma’s not true, sis,” yet another consumer responded.

The slew of problems that introduced Velma to the trending webpage were being adopted by an equivalent quantity of admirers defending Kaling’s selection, pointing out some thing the haters ended up missing about an East Asian version of the character: It is previously been carried out. 

“Scooby-Doo, Exactly where Are You!” the original animated demonstrate that impressed a number of remakes, was established in 1969 and only ran for a calendar year on CBS. It showcased a cast of all white figures, voiced by all white actors, and their dog, Scooby. It’s been reimagined several periods considering that then, like many cartoon and dwell-action variations. 

Around the many years, 12 actresses have voiced animated Velma and four others have performed her in dwell-motion adaptations. In the “Scooby-Doo! The Secret Begins” and “Scooby-Doo! Curse of the Lake Monster,” stay remakes from 2009 and 2010, Velma was portrayed by Hayley Kiyoko, an actress and singer of Japanese descent. Gina Rodriguez, a Puerto Rican actress, voiced Velma in the 2020 animated movie “Scoob!” in which the character also had darker pores and skin.

Pitfalls of reimagining figures as folks of colour

Though some on Twitter made overtly racist reviews about Kaling’s new undertaking, some shared problems that the portrayal of the nerdy Velma as an Asian American performs into the design minority fantasy that Asians are inherently hardworking and studious.

From remaining, cartoon character Scooby-Doo, Nick Palatas, Kate Melton, Robbie Amell and Hayley Kiyoko show up at the 40th birthday celebration of Cesar Millan at the East Valley Animal Shelter in Los Angeles on Sept. 8, 2009.Richard Vogel / APfile

Sociologist Nancy Wang Yuen claimed aspect figures like Velma have the potential to tumble into that entice if they’re one-dimensional. But if the new display is designed about her and presents her a effectively-rounded arc with her personal good friends and love interests, that can be averted. 

“I grew up with ‘Scooby-Doo’ and Velma, and for positive I could truly see her as East Asian,” Yuen explained. “Hopefully not in a product minority way but a quirky way that’s type of bookish but she’s multifaceted. The simple fact that she could be nerdy, that was form of innovative again then.” 

Controversy and racism frequently ensues when persons of colour are solid in historically white roles. In 1997, a are living adaptation of “Cinderella” featured Black singer and songwriter Brandy in the titular role. Though the movie is remembered now as a vintage, it was achieved with racist comments from each viewers and field professionals. A identical backlash followed the announcement of singer Halle Bailey’s casting as Ariel in an impending stay-action model of “The Little Mermaid.”

A “Scooby-Doo” supporter herself, Yuen mentioned she hopes Kaling’s group doesn’t just slap an Asian confront on to the character but as a substitute develops a backstory which is in line with her racial and cultural identification. She also sees the have to have for authentic Asian American stories instead than just the reimagination of previous favorites.

“It’s lazy for Hollywood to just try out to use aged materials and check out to freshen it up when they could actually develop legitimate freshness by centering people today of colour, centering BIPOC tales relatively than just striving to revamp outdated stories,” she reported, referring to Black men and women, Indigenous folks and other persons of coloration. 

When this recycling does not fill the want for Asian American and Pacific Islander illustration in Hollywood, Yuen relevant to Velma as a child and explained she thinks observing her as an Asian American could be exciting. 

“As someone who was an Asian American woman nerd, a particular person who was geeky and nerdy but into manner and all kinds of things, I hope she can embody so substantially a lot more than the nerd,” she stated.   

Velma, an LGBTQ icon 

Fans on Twitter also noted that not only must Velma be a person of shade but she should really also be queer.

Past year, “Scooby-Doo! Secret Incorporated” producer Tony Cervone posted on Instagram that Velma was indeed intended to be gay in his adaptation, which lasted from 2010 to 2013. Cervone stated in his submit that the character was meant to have a romantic partnership with Marcie Fleach, her rival on the display. 

Due to an early cancelation, the two weren’t in a position “to act on their thoughts.” 

Yuen acknowledged how significant the character of Velma is to enthusiasts, herself included, but inspired supporters to set the debate in perspective.

“It’s a fictional character,” she reported. “Scooby-Doo and the gang — it was a conversing canine. For anyone to say, ‘That character is meant to be this,’ I mean, occur on.”